By Dr. Matthew Jones, PsyD, licensed psychologist and cofounder coach
If you don't trust your cofounder anymore, look at what you've stopped saying out loud. Most founders I work with can point to a moment when they quit raising small frustrations and started quietly filing them away. As a licensed psychologist who has worked with hundreds of founding teams, I've seen that the silence does more damage than any single argument, because each of you fills it with an explanation of the other.
What follows is a Q&A on this topic. I hope you find it useful.
Why have I stopped trusting my cofounder?
You've likely stopped trusting your cofounder because a private explanation of their behavior has replaced direct conversation. The first sign usually isn't what gets said in meetings. It's tone. On paper, a discussion between two cofounders can look perfectly civil while the delivery carries irritation, coldness or contempt. When there's goodwill, the two of you can disagree hard and both walk out with a better plan. When there isn't, the same topic lands as an attack, and you start explaining to yourself why your cofounder keeps doing this to you.
Why does my cofounder's behavior bother me so much?
Your reaction to your cofounder depends as much on your history as on their behavior. If your parents were unreliable and your cofounder drops the ball a few times, you're more likely to decide they're incompetent. A cofounder raised by dependable caregivers might watch the same misses and think, this is a rough patch, and I trust you'll turn it around. I'll use myself as an example. I was parentified as a kid, which means I learned early to manage the moods of the adults around me. It made me very attuned to other people, sometimes at my own expense. When I lived in an apartment in Chicago, one unit kept piling trash and boots in the shared hallway instead of taking them to the dumpster. I was furious, and my verdict was instant: these people are selfish. Plenty of people would have shrugged and stepped around it. My reaction was out of proportion because being considerate is something I take pride in. If they're selfish, I get to feel like the considerate one and ignore my own selfishness. So ask yourself what you take pride in and what you judge most harshly in others. Those judgments often point to something you're protecting in yourself.
What happens once I've labeled my cofounder?
Once your story about your cofounder's motives becomes a label for who they are, it keeps going even after the behavior changes. I recently worked with two senior partners at a law firm. One of them had done things that put the firm's reputation at risk, and his partner came to see him as a liability. He stopped doing those things. The label stayed, and his partner used it to justify treating him with contempt. My read is that the partner who thought of himself as the firm's protector was scared. He'd spent decades building that firm, and it was tied to his identity and his income. Staying hard on his colleague felt safer. Dropping the label would have meant risking getting hurt again, and that's the trade-off every founder faces when letting go of a story about a partner.
Why does my cofounder get defensive whenever I bring it up?
Your cofounder gets defensive because by the time you raise the issue, you've usually delivered a verdict instead of a concern. That shows up as a direct accusation, "you're selfish," or a loaded question, "why are you ignoring me?" Either way, you've diagnosed them, and nobody likes being diagnosed. Their defensiveness then looks like proof that you were right. Researchers Kathleen Kennedy and Emily Pronin (2008) found that once we see someone who disagrees with us as biased, we get more combative with them, which makes us look biased in return. They call this the bias-perception conflict spiral. Between cofounders, it can turn every meeting into a fight, or it can go quiet, with both people pulling back and decisions piling up unmade.
How do I know if my story about my cofounder is true?
How strongly you feel a story and whether it's accurate are separate questions. If the same label keeps coming back to you and it upsets you every time, that intensity is a sign you're stuck in a loop. You're probably noticing evidence that fits and missing evidence that doesn't. Even if your read on your cofounder is accurate, it comes from one side of the relationship, so it's incomplete. The narrative therapists Michael White and David Epston (1990) contrasted describing a person by a single problem with describing them through their history, their context and what they value. With cofounders, the second kind of story only comes from putting both perspectives together.
How do I rebuild trust with my cofounder?
You rebuild trust with your cofounder by replacing the private story with a shared one, which takes one honest conversation in four steps. Start with what happened in terms your cofounder would agree with, a specific behavior you both saw, not your theory about their character. Then say how it affected you, in the first person, and what you'd like instead. If your interpretation is taking up a lot of space in your head, say it out loud, but name it as your interpretation rather than a fact. The phrase "the story I'm telling myself is" does a lot of work here. Then listen to their side and change your picture of them to fit what you learn. If you're the one hearing the complaint, acknowledge the impact before you explain what you meant. This is much of what happens in cofounder coaching: two people trading two partial stories for one they can both work from.
Every month you keep score without saying anything, that story gets harder to change, and the company pays for it in the decisions the two of you aren't making together. If you and your cofounder are stuck in this right now, you can book a call with me at https://calendly.com/cofounderclarity/intro, and we'll look at the stories on both sides of the table.
Author Bio
Dr. Matthew Jones is a licensed psychologist and cofounder coach, founder of Cofounder Clarity, and cofounder of the Institute for Founder Dynamics (founderdynamics.org), a nonprofit advancing the science and standards of cofounder partnerships. He is the author of The Cofounder Effect and has worked with hundreds of founding teams. Watch his videos at youtube.com/@CofounderClarity. The Cofounder Coaching Guide (https://cofounderclarity.com/cofounder-coaching): what cofounder coaching is and how it helps two cofounders rebuild one shared story.