How Do I Handle Conflict on a Three-Person Founding Team When I'm Stuck in the Middle?

By Dr. Matthew Jones, PsyD, Licensed Psychologist and cofounder coach

On a three-person founding team, conflict between two cofounders rarely stays between the two of them. It lands on the third. As a Licensed Psychologist who has worked with hundreds of founding teams, I've found that the cofounder holding everything together is often the person keeping the conflict alive, without meaning to.

What follows is a Q&A on this topic. I hope you find it useful.

Why does the conflict between my two cofounders keep going when I'm the one holding it together?

The conflict lasts longer because you're so good at absorbing it. When two of your cofounders clash, you hear about it from both sides, and you pacify both of them. Every cofounder-level decision starts running through separate one-to-one conversations with you first. So it moves at the speed of your calendar, and each of them only hears the softened version of what the other one thinks. The hours you spend translating come straight out of your own job. In almost every three-person founding team I've worked with, I see the same pattern: one person pushing, one person withdrawing, and one person trying to hold it all together. The one holding it together is almost always the one who reaches out to me for coaching.

What are the most common conflict patterns on a three-person founding team?

There are three shapes I see most often: one cofounder criticizes, one withdraws and one mediates; two criticize and one withdraws; or two withdraw and one criticizes. The first is the classic drama triangle, which Stephen Karpman described in 1968. Its three roles are the persecutor, the victim and the rescuer, and people fall into them unconsciously during conflict. Often the two cofounders in the most conflict each believe they're the victim. Psychoanalyst Jessica Benjamin calls this the doer and the done to, where each person feels done to by the other. In the second shape, the two critics reinforce each other's view of the third and form a coalition. The scapegoated cofounder's contribution shrinks, which strengthens the case for pushing them out, and that's how an interpersonal dynamic turns into an equity and separation conversation. In the third shape, the critic feels isolated, the other two keep a surface peace, and the team learns not to bring real issues into meetings, which means a lot more back-channeling.

What is each cofounder actually feeling underneath the conflict?

Each person is dealing with something fundamentally different underneath the behavior. The one criticizing shows frustration on the surface, and underneath is usually fear that the company is going to fail or that they're the only one fighting for it. Criticism is often an attempt to reach someone who feels unreachable, but it lowers psychological safety for everyone, which makes the failure they're afraid of more likely. The one withdrawing is protecting themselves in an environment that doesn't feel safe. The criticism lands on a sense of inadequacy or shame they already carry, so their ownership and output drop, and that hands the critic more evidence. The one holding it together feels responsible for the company surviving and is often frustrated with both of the others. But they soften it, so neither of them gets the feedback they need.

Why does venting to me make my cofounders' conflict worse?

Venting to you makes it worse because it means they never have to go to the person they're frustrated with. This is what I call the Mediator Trap: the most emotionally capable person on a three-person team prevents the partnership from healing by absorbing the friction the system needs to feel in order to change. Family systems therapist Murray Bowen called this a triangle. When anxiety between two people rises, there's a pull for a third person to calm it down, and the conflict stays frozen in place. On a founding team of three, that third point is already built in. While they vent to you, the stories they hold about each other harden and every new interaction adds evidence. By the time it reaches the table, each of them has a full file cabinet of evidence against the other, and a disagreement about one project has become a question of whether they can keep working together at all.

Why do I keep playing peacemaker between my cofounders?

You keep doing it because the role has secondary benefits. It's often a role you learned earlier in life, and you're comfortable in it. You tend to be perceptive. You notice what's going on before others do, which is why people confide in you. Managing the team's conflict also lets you set aside your own frustrations. You get to observe and facilitate the group, which means you're more with the group than in it. You probably feel indispensable, and the role gives you a sense of safety and control. Early on, that's gratifying. But the longer it runs, the more it costs you. Your effectiveness, your emotional capacity and your focus all decrease until your own function starts to slip.

Should we change roles, or should I just step back and let them figure it out?

Neither works. Both seem reasonable on the surface and make it worse. Changing roles and responsibilities is an operational solution to an interpersonal problem, and those never last. Usually it's the one withdrawing whose workload gets cut, so they produce less, feel less included and feel pushed out, which speeds up the team's deterioration. Walking away from the middle and saying "figure it out yourselves" may come from a healthy wish to set a boundary. But the other two don't have the skills or the safety to work through it directly yet. Without a replacement for the role you've been playing, the critic escalates, the one withdrawing pulls back further, and the decisions you used to broker stop getting made at all.

What do I say when my cofounder vents to me about our other cofounder?

Say some version of this: "I'm really glad you're coming to me with this, and I'm game to talk and support you through it, but only if the purpose is to help you figure out how to give this feedback directly to them. I don't want to be the container for all of it. You two need to work on it directly. Are you open to that?" Venting once in a while is a normal human reaction to frustration. When it becomes the dominant pattern, it's time to turn it into specific, actionable feedback and coach them through the conversation. Ask what they need to feel confident, how they'd phrase it, what the most likely outcome is, and what they'd do if their biggest concern came true. The bigger move is getting someone else to facilitate so you can participate in the team rather than run it. In one team I worked with, the CFO had been the go-between for the CEO and CTO. Once I took over facilitation in cofounder coaching, he realized he'd been minimizing his own concerns about the CTO's performance. For the first time, all three were deciding things together in the room.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I do when an employee complains to me about my cofounder?

Make the same move you'd make with a cofounder. Strongly encourage them to take the concern directly to your cofounder, and give them the language and the confidence to do it. Back-channeling through you doesn't change the behavior they're frustrated with. It freezes the conflict in place, and the issue never reaches the one person who can actually change it.

Does resolving cofounder conflict directly mean the partnership will survive?

Not always. In the three-cofounder team I described, once everyone spoke directly, the CEO had built up so much resentment that he was no longer willing to work on the relationship, and the three of them decided together that the CTO would leave. That's a hard outcome. But because they made it directly, they left room for future repair. Stepping out of the middle earlier gives a team more options.

Can cofounder coaching help a three-person founding team?

Yes. A big part of the work is that the coach takes over the facilitation, which lets the cofounder in the middle put that role down. The team moves from separate one-to-one conversations into a group process, and the person who's been translating can finally give direct feedback to both cofounders. Decisions start getting made with all three of you in the room. If you're the one in the middle right now, every week you stay there, the decisions that need all three of you keep waiting and your team's chances of repair get smaller. If you and your cofounders are in this, book a call with me at https://calendly.com/cofounderclarity/intro, and we'll look at what's keeping the three of you stuck.

Author Bio

Dr. Matthew Jones is a Licensed Psychologist and cofounder coach, founder of Cofounder Clarity, and cofounder of the Institute for Founder Dynamics (founderdynamics.org), a nonprofit advancing the science and standards of cofounder partnerships. He is the author of The Cofounder Effect and has worked with hundreds of founding teams. Watch his videos at youtube.com/@CofounderClarity.

What Is Cofounder Coaching? — https://cofounderclarity.com/cofounder-coaching — The full explanation of the work this post points to when the person in the middle steps out.

Next
Next

How Do You Test a Cofounder Before You Commit?